Home | Contact | Links

Featured Content
About First Touch
The best soccer fanzine in the USA for the past ten years.
Archives
Read all the articles from previous weeks' FirstTouch.

The Store
Authentic Club jerseys, DVDs, and much more!

Photo Gallery
Our archive of footie fotos, available for stock and personal use.
Broadcast Schedule
Listings of upcoming US broadcasts of live matches.
Where to Watch
Our complete list of area bars showing live matches!
FirstTouch Desktops
Show your allegiance with original FirstTouch desktop art!
Cosmopolitan League
This week's action in the NYC area's amateur league.

West Ham dodge a bullet


Dave Bowler

5/21/07

Yes, we were naïve. Let’s admit it - confession is good for the soul after all. All those years ago, we came blindly into this Premier League idea thinking that such an extraordinarily wealthy institution would know exactly what it was doing, that it would be a smoothly running, well oiled machine, acting justly and equitably on behalf of all its members, irrespective of size or status.

Actually, no, that’s not true. How stupid would it have been to imagine that? But we never expected it to be this much of a shambles. Nor that it would be so barefaced as it has been in the case of West Ham, who finally wrestled their way out of the bottom three last Sunday.

Congratulations to them on the way they set about the job of surviving, but let’s make no bones about it. They should be long, long relegated by now after the Tevez affair. Nobody doubts that Tevez is a fine player, nor that he has been the inspiration behind their recent run of results.

But neither can anyone doubt that he should not have played for the Hammers. All the evidence clearly points to the fact that from the day he “signed” he was ineligible according to the rulebook. And whenever a team plays an ineligible player, there is a points deduction, without any question.

In the case of Bury, they were even thrown out of the competition this season for that very offence. Which is how it should be. Playing an ineligible player is essentially cheating and ignorance is no defence.

According to every precedent, West Ham should have lost points for every game in which Tevez and his compatriot Mascherano appeared. Instead, apparently for no other reason than the season is getting on a bit, there’s a fine instead - that’s like saying that murdering a centenarian isn’t as serious as murdering a teenager.

The price of a place in the Premier League next season - the most lucrative season ever when West Ham are guaranteed something like £50 million - is £5.5million, the fine West Ham got in place of a points deduction. If that’s the admission fee, I can find you 75 clubs quite willing to stump it up - wouldn’t you put your cash on a bet that’s guaranteed to come in at 10-1? Let’s all do it and have a 92 team Premier League. I know there’s no precedent, but if the Premiership is selling seats at the top table, shouldn’t we all get chance to pay to play?

Yes, it is sad for the Hammers fans, but not as sad as it is for Sheffield United’s, the fall guys. Sunderland and Birmingham probably aren’t ecstatic either - they might have fancied their chances of finishing above the Blades next year, but West Ham? Less appealing.

For those in the Championship, a shambolic West Ham, coming down in disarray might offer a less threatening option than a focused United who know all there is to know about the Football League. If the ruling is not overturned, the integrity of both the Premiership and the Championship will have been compromised for seasons to come.

And accuse me of paranoia if you like, but do you really think that if Watford, Sheffield United or Wigan had been in the dock, they’d have escaped with a fine? Nope. They’d have fallen victim to the Premier League’s ethnic cleansing that’s designed to only allow “big clubs” to survive.

Don’t think that’s as far fetched as it sounds. You only have to hear the erstwhile Arsenal head honcho, David Dein, waxing lyrical about the way American sport is run to realise that the days of a NFL style franchise system is the end game for those at the top.

Create an hermetically sealed top tier, impervious to attack from outside, and then relegate the rest of us to the role of feeder clubs, akin to college football in the States, and you’ve got rid of that pesky element of competition that those Luddites keep wittering on about. We’re the best and, so long as we don’t let anybody else play against us, we will always be the best. QED. all of which ignores he fact that the US and the UK actually are separate cuontries with different traditions, different geography and different sporting history. Replacing one culture with another, in either transatlantic direction, is ludicrous.

Listen to the complaints of the big boys that some members of their 50 strong playing staff don’t get the competition they should, that their reserves team should play in the Championship instead of Scunthorpe. Listen to the pathetic arguments that some of them - the richest ones inevitably - trot out when they’re preventing the television money being distributed around the national game.

Look at the way that any handouts - irritating small change found down the back of the sofa and dumped in a collecting tin - are only given to the Championship in an effort to divide and rule the Football League clubs.

You might not have much time for the Football Association, but the worst they can be charged with is incompetence. It’s the Premier League - who, tellingly, have dropped the “FA” from their branding - that has the shark infested waters. If only Robert Shaw was still alive...



FirstTouch is published weekly by David Witchard
©2007, David Witchard/FirstTouch Online

Contact Us

FirstTouch Online is best viewed with Apple's Safari 1.x or Internet Explorer 5.x, at a minimum screen resolution of 800x600 dpi